DeGeneres Leaving ‘Idol,’ Says It Was Bad Fit
by The Associated Press
What??? Really?? I just saw this tweet from NPR announcing that Ellen Degeneres is not returning to American Idol. I know that she wasn’t overly critical and maybe was too much of a cheerleader, but I felt like she spoke for us as the average viewer and I think she was (is) funny! Our whole family did. I also felt like she was an improvement over the goofy Paula.
Simon’s gone and now Ellen. And, I just heard on the Today Show that Kara may be out too. That would leave just Randy. I did hear that Bret Michaels (of Poison), Justin Timberlake, and even Jennifer Lopez were all being considered as replacements. That seems like a lot for one show.
When the show first aired, I did not watch it. My family did. All of them, but me. I was too freakin’ busy with work at my crazy-ass 60-hr a week job. “I’m making money, people! I don’t have time for family fun!”
When I entered the slower lane, I joined the ritual known as American Idol. I was hooked after Season 5 which was my initiation. Now, I look forward to it every January!
With this announcement, I’m torn. Will it be the same? Who will the new judge or judges be (do we really need 4 judges?)? My oldest said that she won’t watch it now that Simon and Ellen are gone. It was the one show that the entire family could watch together. The girls now like to watch overly dramatic teenagery shows like “The Secret Life of the American Teenager” and “Pretty Little Liars”. My 10-yr-old son cannot and does not want to watch these shows (the hubby and I don’t either). American Idol was the only “family friendly” show appropriate for all ages in our household that everyone liked. Bummer.
Maybe this will be a good time to start weaning ourselves off of this show. It’s a commitment and very time-consuming – in the beginning it takes up two or three nights a week!
It would leave me more time to develop my painting or maybe even a brand new hobby. . . . . .what would it be?
My family likes So You Think You Can Dance… you could try that. It actually might not be that bad if Kara leaves and they bring on JT or someone else that has some credibility. I am a huge Ellen fan, just not on that show.
We’ve been watching Wipe Out – have you seen that one? It’s pretty funny and doesn’t require you to come back week after week. If you miss one, it’s no big deal.
Regarding AI, my middle one was never really a fan of Kara’s either. It might be a good thing that she is not coming back. I could see JT on the show but not Bret or J-Lo.
We DVR the Ellen show because we all love to watch it – the girls especially. She is funnier on her talk show.